India Rejects Pannun's US Lawsuit as "Baseless" After New York Court Seeks Delhi Courts' Help to Serve Summons on Doval, Ex-RAW Chief
Quick summary
India has rejected Gurpatwant Singh Pannun's US civil lawsuit against NSA Ajit Doval and former RAW chief Samant Goel, after a New York federal court asked three Delhi district courts to help serve the summonses.
India has rejected a civil lawsuit filed in the United States by Gurpatwant Singh Pannun against National Security Adviser Ajit Doval and former RAW chief Samant Goel. The move follows an order from a New York federal court asking courts in Delhi to help deliver the summons to the two officials. The Ministry of External Affairs called the suit baseless and said it rejects it.
What the court order says
In an order dated 13 November, US District Judge Katherine Polk Failla of the Southern District of New York told the court clerk to send the summons and related documents to the Patiala House District Court for Doval, and to the Dwarka and Tis Hazari district courts for Goel. The judge asked the Indian courts to assist in serving the defendants. The court also asked the receiving courts to send back a written account of the steps taken.
As reported, the order notes that earlier attempts to serve the documents through India's designated Central Authority under the Hague Convention did not succeed. The court therefore allowed an alternative route under Article 19 of the convention. India's Code of Civil Procedure lets summonses from certain notified foreign civil courts be passed to Indian courts and served in the same way as domestic documents. An earlier order, dated 9 November, had granted Pannun's request to use this route.
India's response
On 10 November, Foreign Ministry spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal rejected what he called fabricated and malicious attacks on senior officials, and dismissed the suit as frivolous. He said any request to serve judicial documents in India can only be routed through the designated Central Authority, which is the Ministry of Law and Justice. When the ministry was asked again about the US court's directive, it repeated its position on Friday and dismissed the lawsuit.
Who is Pannun
Pannun is a prominent figure in Sikhs for Justice, an organisation banned in India. India has designated him a terrorist under its anti-terror law, and he is wanted by Indian authorities in several cases. His lawsuit alleges that Doval and Goel conspired to assassinate him, and it also names the Government of India and other individuals, including Nikhil Gupta. India has consistently said the allegations have no merit.
What the order does and does not mean
The order deals only with how the documents are delivered. It does not mean that Doval and Goel have already received the summons, or that any court has found them responsible for the alleged conspiracy. The US government is not a party to the civil lawsuit.
Tags
- Pannun lawsuit
- Ajit Doval
- Samant Goel
- US court summons
- Southern District of New York
- Hague Convention service of summons
- MEA Randhir Jaiswal
- Sikhs for Justice
- India US relations
- Patiala House Court
- Judge Katherine Polk Failla
- Nikhil Gupta